Frame from The great porn experiment | Gary Wilson | TEDxGlasgow Plays with YouTube's privacy-enhanced embed

The great porn experiment | Gary Wilson | TEDxGlasgow

Open on YouTube First HN thread

10 HN users recommended this talk in 11 different months between 2012 and 2023.

2007–2026
4 strong recommendations 7 recommendations 3 citations HackerTube score 13

HN commenters frequently recommend it as an eye-opening case against heavy porn use, though it is contested science.

Gary Wilson's TEDxGlasgow talk argues that internet pornography hyperstimulates the brain's reward system and can cause symptoms that reverse when people stop. TED notes that several claims are not supported by respected academic studies.

Pull quote: “Here's an enlightening video on the detrimental effects of porn on the brain.” (HN, 2018)

Also tagged: porn addiction, dopamine, addiction, internet pornography, neuroscience, tedx

What Hacker News said

14 labeled comments from the HN archive; up to 20 are kept per video, favoring different commenters. Each one links back to the original thread.

Strongly recommends Theodores December 2013 under The UK "Porn" Filter Blocks Kids' Access To Tech, Civil Liberties Websites
Plausible science-based reason to avoid porn
Read the full comment
Here is the truth - watch too much porn and you get erectile dysfunction: [this video] Why did it take me decades to find someone able to present that reasonably plausible reason as to why I should definitely not want to watch porn under any circumstances whatsoever? The argument (with science) in the above TED talk is that if you do watch a lot of porn then you are not going to aroused by real women as much as you should, leading to unsatisfactory bedroom performances. Yep, porn is actually that dangerous. I might not care for the traditional 'don't watch porn because it is porn'/'think of the children'/'porn exploits women' arguments, however, I do have enlightened self interest and loss of libido is so not what I want to have. If I was in the UK government I would want to get this message out to kids in schools, not to scare them away from porn for the sake of it, but because they deserve to have 'normal', happy sexual health. By censoring porn they are not going to get this message, in fact they will be further away from it than they are now, doing what they can to get the 'forbidden fruit' instead of knowing why they just should not bother. Instead of censoring they could have demanded that there be a banner on the pages of porn sites warning that use of porn leads to erectile dysfunction. This would be a proactive move, no harder to get into law than that stupid 'this site uses cookies' directive. They could get the ISPs to do it so porn from outer Mongolia would be suitably
Strongly recommends cyberpunk October 2016 under UK Government proposes porn-viewing ID
Eye-opening and worrying points about porn
[this video] ^^ This really opened my eyes to this problem for me.. It's really rather worrying, and I guess my generation (early 30s) were the last to avoid this so it's kind of invisible to us because of how awkward it is to talk about such things. We need to do something, perhaps better education and getting more comfortable talking about sex and relationships with young people is a better approach than failed-from-the-outset restrictions... Either way, the points in that video are imo, valid, and should worry everyone.
Strongly recommends sizzle November 2018 under Ask HN: Resources for introverted devs to learn workplace politics?
Neural reward system effects of porn
Read the full comment
Also, an often overlooked topic of modern times, high speed internet pornography + chronic masturbation and its numbing effects on our neural reward system which makes things like eye contact and social activities unbearable and highly disconcerting. This addiction isn't talked about much because it is almost a universal coping mechanism for guys beginning in adolescence, but you have nothing to lose in trying to abstain and see if your social anxiety melts away. At worst you just determine that it's something else like depression and can go seek out a proper medical diagnosis. The crazy thing about the social anxiety inducing effects of chronic masturbation is that it is not taught in medical school and doctors do not diagnose or advise that it can be detrimental to people's lives, granted you are oblivious to the hormonal imbalances it causes w.r.t. neuroscience (orgasm induced prolactin release suppressing dopamine in neural pleasure/reward system). Great Ted talk on subject: [this video]
Strongly recommends PKop February 2022 under Inside Pornhub
Very informative on physiological effects of porn
Read the full comment
Midwest US, mid 30's. This sort of view is strongly held by the intellectual and political circles I support and follow. I think it is a very insidious and corrupting addiction, and the modern incarnation of it is orders of magnitude more stimulating than in prior eras. Infinite access to a stimulus that simulates in male brains "mating" with ever varied women, which is hijacking a strong biological imperative. As another comment mentioned a similar problem with "advertising" in general, I think sexualization and over stimulus of the population weakens people, and not to say there is some conspiracy purposefully pushing this (it may just emergent from technology and human instinct) I do think the corrupting influence weakens a population and makes them more easily dominated by strong forces... media, business, government, etc. All to say that, in terms of "what is best to cultivate a strong society and people" porn is extremely antithetical to this. A stronger society is one that would be avoiding, however necessary, consumption and production of pornography. This presentation [0] on the physiological effects of porn consumption is very informative. Observations mirror what strong opiates do to the brain A good overview of the public health problem of porn[1] The psychologically destabilizing and weakening effects of porn, and how they breakdown willpower to oppose stronger forces are illustrated by the time when the Israeli military broadcast pornography onto the televisions
Recommends msluyter January 2013 under Did porn warp me forever?
Empirical grounding for article's anecdote
On the same topic, "The Great Porn Experiment" TED talk, which provides some empirical grounding for the anecdote in the article: [this video]
Suggests resetting dopamine circuits to regain motivation
Porn can create/maintain different thinking patterns, underhabituate you for normal real-life cues. By withdrawing and resensitizing your dopamine circuits you might jumpstart your motivation, getting more fun and getting out of the rut. Shouldn't expect a miracle but may worth a try. [this video] good luck!
Recommends diadara March 2014 under Hexagon 16384
Addiction effects on the brain like hard drugs
[this video] Have you seen this TED talk about porn addiction and how it has similar effects like some sort of hard drug addiction on the brain. Everything uses the same pipeline.
Recommends PKop May 2018 under Pornography and the Butterfly Effect
Enlightening on detrimental brain effects of porn
Here's an enlightening video on the detrimental effects of porn on the brain. Porn addiction shows similar effects as opiates. [this video] Related: "NoFap" [link]
Recommends trident1000 December 2020 under Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform
Good TED talks on societal issues from porn
Read the full comment
Ive watched porn all my life (like most). I dont have a moral vendetta against it. But it seems to be a no-go topic for discussing the serious societal issues from porn. As I've grown older ive realized its really very toxic and probably the most widespread addiction in the US causing real issues. When you watch porn all day or even just a few times per week, your testosterone and hormonal balance as a man changes. You do not go after women and start a family. You are more likely to be depressed. It causes brain fog and mood disorders. Etc. Theres some good TED talks on this which are easy to find. This is never talked about and should be. Little off topic maybe but just wanted to state this. [this video]
Recommends Korpocalypse April 2021 under Ask HN: How Do You Optimize Your Intake of Information?
Related talk on dopamine, internet and novelty seeking
Read the full comment
related ted talk on dopamine, the internet, and novelty seeking [this video] also related: the modern diet contains alot of calorically dense food, which means less stomach and intenstinal stretching, which means more ghrelin, which activates these novelty-seeking dopaminergic systems in the brain as for the original question: a) as far as optimizing, I think that approaching the optimal state is less important than making improvements to a consistent performance ethic. Better to do something a little better every day than to miss days trying to do it better than everybody else. b) with information, I tend to focus on information that relates to a particular goal relevant to job performance or general wellbeing and then take notes on any new information and review prior notes relevant to the newest information in order to build an intuitive mental logical structure of the problem/goal and all of its moving parts. But since so few things are scientifically provable, I try to "bet" on certain things based on how more or less likely they are and an informal cost-benefit analysis
Recommends nashashmi June 2023 under Falcon LLM – A 40B Model
Offered as academic knowledge in a debate
And you know this because you’re the expert of knowing what is morality? Decades of people telling you it is immoral, yet somehow you come along to say the opposite and hope people believe it? The only justification you can give is an ad hominem attack accusing the other person of not knowing what they are talking about. Try a little bit of academic knowledge here: [this video]

Citations, criticism and jokes

Cites it scrrr September 2013 under Teenagers and the Internet
Cited as proof too much porn is bad
Apparently there's some proof that too much pornography is bad for you. [1] Not too mention all the multitasking. Other than that the Internet is like every other thing. It has good and bad sides. I, for one, have faith in teenagers. They'll turn out alright. It's usually the old folks that make the bigger/worse mistakes. [1] [this video]
Cited as evidence of harm from porn
Read the full comment
There is plenty of evidence of harm from porn usage, it hijacks the brain in a similar manner as hard core drugs. [0] The social consequences are pretty obvious, satisfying fundemental bioligical needs through artifical manner degrades what those desires are meant to achieve: family formation, marriages, which it inhibits forming or ruins those that already exist. Go spend some time on the no-fap sub-reddit to see the massive positive change that occurs when men quit consuming porn. Porn is a tool for social control, pacification and weakening culture [1], it is not empowering for either side of the equation. If this wasn't true, it wouldn't have been used as a form of psychological warfare like it was in this situation [2]. Did they do this to "empower" their enemy? [0] [this video] [1] [link] [2] [link]

Keyboard shortcuts

/
Search
j k
Next / previous video in a list
Enter
Open the focused video
l
Like (on a video page)
w
Watch later (on a video page)
?
This help
Esc
Close