Frame from Why It Was Almost Impossible to Make the Blue LED Plays with YouTube's privacy-enhanced embed

Why It Was Almost Impossible to Make the Blue LED

Open on YouTube First HN thread

10 HN users recommended this documentary in 7 different months between 2024 and 2026.

2007–2026
2 strong recommendations 8 recommendations 5 citations HackerTube score 8

HN recommends it as a gripping story of single-minded persistence against the herd, and as the back story behind modern LED lighting.

Veritasium tells the story of how Shuji Nakamura and others made the blue LED, long thought nearly impossible. It covers the materials challenge of gallium nitride and the persistence it took.

Pull quote: “is goes into great detail on what it took to make the blue LED. It's quite fascinating.” (HN, 2024)

Also tagged: invention of the blue led, blue led, nakamura, gallium nitride, invention, persistence

What Hacker News said

15 labeled comments from the HN archive; up to 20 are kept per video, favoring different commenters. Each one links back to the original thread.

Strongly recommends teleforce March 2026 under In Edison’s Revenge, Data Centers Are Transitioning From AC to DC
Back story of the blue LED and GaN
Read the full comment
>It is absolutely stupid to talk about this as edisons revenge. If Tesla had the modern high power transistors needed to get high voltage dc out of the ac produced from a spinning turbine he would be all for high voltage dc too. This! The soon people realized these facts the better. The pervasive high rise buildings did not happen before the invention of modern cranes. Exactly twenty years ago I was doing a novel research on GaN characterization, and my supervisors made a lot money with consulations around the world, and succesfully founded govt funded start-up company around the technology. Together with SiC, these are the two game changing power devices with wideband semiconductor technology that only maturing recently. Heck, even the Nobel price winning blue LED discovery was made feasible by GaN. Watch the excellent video made by Veritasium for this back story [1]. [1] Why It Was Almost Impossible to Make the Blue LED: [this video]
Story of someone who worked harder than everyone else
The Veritasium youtube channel has a few interesting videos related to this topic: This one is on IQ: [link] Pay attention to the stats on how IQ correlates to success (near the end). This one is about becoming an expert: [link] This one is about someone who just worked harder than everyone else: [this video]
History of blue LED development
Veritasium had this video about the history of sewing machines recently [1]. I remember watching it and ended up in awe of how something that we take for granted took a journey of several thousand years to be get invented. While I'm thinking about it, his recent video about the development of blue LEDs [2] is very interesting as well if you haven't seen it. [1] [link] [2] [this video]
Extreme example of a rebel researcher defying the herd
Read the full comment
I think that this is a general trend. Various fields tend to get into groupthink, and it is hard for people who buck the trend to pursue the usual academic path to research. But usually the herd has gone down a wrong turn, and it is up to a random rebel to make the next key discovery. For an extreme example, I recommend Veratasium's video on blue LEDs, [this video] . But despite how extreme that example is, it does seem to be a trend. The direction that the herd has gone has been generally well-explored simply because a herd of researchers have already gone there. If they've found nothing, you'll probably find nothing either. So you have to back up. Sadly, the way that academia is structured discourages this at every turn. :-(
Recommends Centigonal April 2025 under
Fascinating example of single-minded researcher supported by patrons
The human race has benefited greatly from individual researchers who made their work the main source of value in their life, and from societies, patrons, and government institutions who gave these people the stability and financial support to pursue such a single minded focus. Two fascinating examples: [link] [this video]
Recommends Eddy_Viscosity2 March 2026 under Just make it hard to fail
Blue LED inventor worked every single day
The guy who figured out how to make a blue LED (which was world changing), also worked every single day . Fascinating story: [this video]

Citations, criticism and jokes

Cites it nextaccountic March 2024 under EFF: Tell Congress: We Can't Afford More Bad Patents
Blue LED inventor was shortchanged by his company
In real life, the inventor of the blue led was basically scammed by his company. The company earned a lot of money and basically shifted the whole business to produce blue leds. Veritasium recently made a video about that [this video] I think this illustrate another point: patents should protect inventors, not companies. Companies shouldn't be able to amass a "portfolio" of patents to bully their competition either.
Cites it Pet_Ant April 2024 under The Rise and Fall of Silicon Graphics
Example of an individual ignoring company direction and succeeding
And yet there are stories of people ignoring the company direction, continuing work, and saving the company. See: The Blue LED [this video] So it’s not clear that the company knows better. Feels like educated guesses but a lof of luck involved.
Cites it aurareturn January 2025 under Jevons paradox
LED makers saw exponential revenue growth
Is this true? What were the revenues of lighting companies before compared to now? Do we count TV screen makers because they’re LEDs as well? I just watched Veritasium’s video on how LEDs were indented and the companies making LEDs saw exponential increase in revenue. [this video] Basic Google search tells me the lighting industry has experienced high growth due to the invention of LED lighting.

Keyboard shortcuts

/
Search
j k
Next / previous video in a list
Enter
Open the focused video
l
Like (on a video page)
w
Watch later (on a video page)
?
This help
Esc
Close