Plays with YouTube's privacy-enhanced embed

The Origins of Russian Authoritarianism

Name: The Origins of Russian Authoritarianism
Description: Kraut traces centuries of political development, from Mongol rule and the Orthodox church to Muscovite autocracy, that shaped Russia's authoritarian state. It uses countryball animation and compares Russia with Europe and China.

Kraut Explainers intro

Open on YouTube First HN thread

3 HN users recommended this explainer in 3 different months between 2022 and 2023.

2007–2026

3 recommendations 1 citation 2 critical HackerTube score 3

HN recommends it as a good introduction to Russian authoritarianism, though some commenters say it is flawed or wrong on many points.

Kraut traces centuries of political development, from Mongol rule and the Orthodox church to Muscovite autocracy, that shaped Russia's authoritarian state. It uses countryball animation and compares Russia with Europe and China.

Pull quote: “this video gives a good introduction to the origins of Russian Authoritarianism” (HN, 2022)

Also tagged: russian political history, russia, authoritarianism, mongol rule, history, countryballs

What Hacker News said

6 labeled comments from the HN archive; up to 20 are kept per video, favoring different commenters. Each one links back to the original thread.

Recommends bilegeek July 2022 under Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship

Gets the gist of Russian absolutism across, though imperfect

>How does it get to this point? I would imagine because, going back to even before Soviet times, all the people who do care are either disappeared or flee, leaving behind only the people who are too jaded to effectively resist. Russian absolutism is generally more, well, absolute than other places. Though it's imperfect, a video[1] by Kraut gets the gist across. [1] [this video]

View on Hacker News

Recommends throwaways85989 August 2022 under Mikhail Gorbachev has died

Best description of Russian cultural background found

It was not really a base for capitalism to take hold and effect. It needs a basic rule of law and democracy to work. All it got was brief window of chaos, before the kleptocracy returned. Best description of the cultural background i found so far was this: [this video]

View on Hacker News

Recommends lambic2 December 2022 under Facial Recognition Tech Gets Woman Booted from Rockettes Show Due to Employer

Good introduction to origins of Russian authoritarianism compared with China and Europe

I doubt this question can be answered in a short comment. The differences stem from thousands of years of diverging cultural influences, history and geography. As for Russia, this video gives a good introduction to the origins of Russian Authoritarianism (with comparison to power structures in China and Europe over history), that go all the way back to the 5th century A.D. with the Huns and the unique geography/climate of Russia: [this video] .

View on Hacker News

Citations, criticism and jokes

Cites it scottLobster April 2023 under Russia is persecuting dissenters by taking away their children

Linked as support for claim about Russian authoritarianism

Russians have never had any real individual rights. Throughout their history the common people have just been resources enslaved to brutal overlords. The Soviets were perhaps somewhat softer overlords on average, but the principle remains. The state will dispose of disobedient people the same way it would dispose of rotten potatoes. [this video]

View on Hacker News

Pushes back aurizon March 2022 under What the Russian Invasion Has Done to Ukraine

Total BS, NATO was a totally defensive alliance against the well known expansionary aims of the USSR - who fostered conquest and dictatorial regimes that gave zero power to the people. How many communist regimes have democratically elected governments? Write it on this piece of paper - no pen needed - there are none at all. [this video]

View on Hacker News

Pushes back dhdjjd March 2022 under What the Russian Invasion Has Done to Ukraine

Read the full comment

It's just wrong on so many points it's just difficult to argue it. Russians didn't build castles: they did and they also had castle-like monasteries (even the Moscow stone Kremlin has been built during the Mongol yoke). Using Polish flags of the 16th century as an illustration is also at best misleading [this video] The black plague had almost no impact because the black plague was very limited in Russia. All this stuff about aristocracy competing for the favor of the monarch just disregards that almost every Romanov monarch was a result of a coup by aristocracy Russian church was independent till Aleksei Mikhailovich and we still have old-believers. It completely disregards the fact that during Ivan the Terrible rule Siberia was conquered by an independent knyaz (it was basically a private entity). Comparing Russia to China is based on economic developments of the last 30 years. 40 years ago Russia was a super-state while China was recovering from its Cultural revolution. We don't know what is going to happen in the next 30 years. Nowadays Russia in some points is less centralised than even European union.

View on Hacker News