HackerTubewatch
Surprise me
Frame from Try this bizarre audio illusion! ๐Ÿ‘๏ธ๐Ÿ‘‚๐Ÿ˜ฎ - BBC Plays via YouTube's privacy-enhanced embed

Try this bizarre audio illusion! ๐Ÿ‘๏ธ๐Ÿ‘‚๐Ÿ˜ฎ - BBC

10 videos recommended on HN
YouTube
2 HN users recommended this demo2 months2011โ€“2020 score 2
Years with an HN recommendation, 2007โ€“2026

HN uses it as the standard demonstration that the brain reinterprets perception, in threads on speech, AI audio and illusions.

A BBC Horizon clip demonstrating the McGurk effect, where the same audio sounds like different syllables depending on the mouth movements you see. It shows that people integrate visual speech information into what they hear.

โ€œThe most compelling illustration I've seen of this is the McGurk Affect[1].โ€ (HN, 2012)

2 recommendations ยท 12 citations ยท 1 critical ยท Demos

15 Hacker News comments

From the HN archive; up to 20 kept per video, favoring different commenters. Recommendations first.

Citations, criticism and jokes

@joeyo Dec 2012 Cites it
on HN thread My journey to a cochlear implant
> The disbelief came when it was time to listen to singular > words. With the screen turned off, I got 0%. With the > screen turned on, I got 8%. Thatโ€™s crazy! It's really amazing how pervasive (putatively Bayesian) multisensory integration of information is in the brain. Even individuals without impaired hearing have their auditory perceptions strongly a affected by other inputs. The McGurk effect is a great example of this: [link] [this video]
Example of vision altering auditory perception
@forgottenpaswrd Feb 2013 Cites it
on HN thread Is speed reading really possible?
Sub vocalizing is the fact or reading syllables instead of entire words at once. Deaf could find very useful to vocalize words as they could read peoples lips and faces based on those units. Everybody read lips and faces subconsciously, there are famous illusions in witch people hear different sounds with the same sound file depending of the video of a mouth they watch: [this video]
Illusion showing mouth video changes heard sound
@joeyo Jul 2013 Cites it
on HN thread Why you think your phone is vibrating when it is not
Read more
There is a considerable body of evidence that "top-down" processes affect not only how sensory evidence is processed, but how the sensations themselves are experienced. In other words, high-level (but subconscious) neural "judgments" about the statistics of the world, actually influence how you perceive it. To put it still another way: sensations aren't simply passively experienced; they are actively constructed by the brain. Phantom phone vibration is, in many ways, just as "constructed" as real phone vibration. Perceptual illusions provide one of the clearest ways to show that sensations reflect factors other than external stimuli. Here are two illusions, in different sensory modalities, that demonstrate the strong top-down influence of the brain on perception: The rubber hand illusion [1,2] and the McGurk effect [3,4]. The rubber hand illusion is particularly relevant because it is quite similar to the phantom phone vibration effect. 1. [link] 2. [link] 3. [link] 4. [this video] EDIT: Here's an additional example to consider. People generally can't tickle themselves. The sensations are less strong when one touches oneself than when someone else does so. The explanation for this is that the brain automatically discounts sensations which arise as a result of self-motion. This has obvious advantages, namely that you don't constantly overstimulate yourself just in the process of moving through the world and are as such better able to attend to important externally generated stimuli
Example of top-down brain influence on perception
@srean Jun 2014 Cites it
on HN thread A Sound You Can't Unhear (And What It Says About Your Brain)
Read more
It is really interesting and amusing how persistent certain 'illusions' can be even when one is exposed to it just once and for a short time. Fun story, this was a long time ago: I was interning at Google at that time. One day I tell my then cube neighbor about an interesting experiment on visual perception that I had read about. A professor at MIT had carried out experiments on his class. Students were asked to wear prismatic goggles that shifted their vision and then try to catch objects. Hilarity ensued, but soon enough the brain adapted to the shift. Same with inverting glasses, soon the students would not even realize that their vision was inverted. The fun part was when they took their glasses off, their motor reflexes would still compensate assuming that they were wearing those glasses. Much hilarity again. I was telling all this to my cube neighbor Michael Riley, not knowing who he was, he says with a twinkle in his eye "Yeah, that was us". The most remarkable thing about these experiments that I learned from him was that the professor would provoke an illusion on the students on the first day of class. I dont remember exactly what the illusion was, but it was some visual artifact, seeing patterns that werent visible a moment ago, much like the OP. At the end of the semester the professor would demonstrate that the entire class could still see that illusion, although they have not been exposed to it in the intervening 4 months ! I tried hard to find an articles on the
Linked in discussion of persistent perceptual illusions
@sho_hn Dec 2014 Cites it
on HN thread Ways to learn a language as an adult?
Read more
I originally started with web resources, but here's the stuff I credit with really advancing me properly, roughly in the order I read or used it: 1. TTMIK's Hangeul Master . It's really easy to pick up hangul basics so spending $20 on a book that's superficially just about the alphabet might seem silly. But the harder part to learn isn't really the symbols, it's the pronunciation. You need to get to grips with the various sound change rules that apply when various characters are adjacent to each other, and with the pronunciation differences between the normal and tense consonants, and so on. If you can't look at a word and confidently form its sound in your head you can't read or write efficiently, so this is crucial. TTMIK's book is really a solid package: You get the basics (the symbols, the stroke order, etc.) but also a good introduction to the sound change rules, not just on paper but also in really well-done supplementary audio resources and quizzes (where many books fail). Finally there's a second section on various Korean handwriting styles that I found surprisingly useful (Korean TV shows and other materials often use pen scripts that can be hard to read without spending some time with this). 2. To complement the above, the Korean Wiki Project has a lot of good sound files for various character combinations. 3. Billy Go's two Korean Made Simple books are just great. They're highly accessible introductions to core grammar and core vocab, with short, digestible chapter
Tangential illusion link in language learning comment
@anotheryou Jun 2016 Cites it
on HN thread AI produces realistic sounds that fool humans
Fooling humans is much easier when about 50% of the sound is always accurate (in any case it's a wooden drumstick hitting something). The human mind is very forgiving, especially when vision accompanies sound (McGurk effect [1]) Furthermore this fixed variable makes the pool of samples to choose from much much smaller. Still impressive of course ;) just far from dubbing any video there is. [1] [this video]
Shows vision shaping what sound we perceive
@anotheryou Apr 2018 Cites it
on HN thread Looking to Listen: Audio-Visual Speech Separation
I wonder if we will have visual assisted tts. Humans do it: [this video] The McGurk illusion is so strong that I'm sure visual cues have a major role in error correction or voice recognition assistance for humans.
Shows visual cues strongly affect human speech perception
@zawerf May 2018 Cites it
on HN thread A tool that lets you hear both Yanny and Laurel
Are you talking about the McGurk effect? You hear either Ba or Fa depending on which you expect to hear based on the lip reading (but the sound that is actually playing is Va): [this video] It is really cool that small contextual information can change our senses so dramatically without us being aware of it happening.
Explains ba/fa illusion where lip reading changes heard sound
@jml7c5 Jun 2019 Cites it
on HN thread Kill Instant Messaging
>For some reason I can easily understand people on video chat even if they have strong accent whereas I can't grok anything on a phone call. See the McGurk Effect: [this video]
Explains why video chat is easier to understand

Video list and Hacker News comment labels from HackerTube (prompted by @karpathy), released under ODC-By 1.0, built on the open-index/hacker-news archive. Hacker News data is provided by Y Combinator; comments remain the work of their authors. Video titles, channel names and thumbnails belong to their creators and are shown via YouTube. HackerTube Watch is an unofficial edition. Data export of 2026-10-31.

Keyboard shortcuts

/
Search
j k
Next / previous video
r
Surprise me
l
Like (video page)
w
Watch later (video page)
?
This help
Esc
Close